Even before I've completed all the medallions, I decided to start testing the other rows to make sense of the pattern and see how everything fits together. The piece you're seeing therefore is messy as it's all just testing: there's knots and loose threads and different elements that I've tried out so it looks disorganised at the moment. But once I've figured out what I'm doing, I will cut it all out and start again.
Yes, there are many problems with this pattern! As can often be the case with vintage patterns, I just cannot make things fit as per the way the pattern is written. If I try to follow just as is indicated, elements end up all crammed in in places but mostly, the collar just won't curve as it should. If I make the neck edge as written, the curve is practically non existent, you'd end up with an edging rather than a collar.
I don't really know what's so different as I feel that my medallions look pretty much like the ones in the photo in the book... so why can't I get everything else to fit around them?
I'm determined to make this work though, even if it will mean adjusting the pattern so that I end up with the right shape and with all elements fitting well with each other.
The finished collar will therefore not be exactly like the one in the book - I feel the changes will be mostly around the neckline - but it will still look close to the original.
Examining it again, I think that my medallions are perhaps tighter/smaller than the ones in the book which would affect all the elements around... but still I don't see that it should cause that many problems.
I'll keep at it!
Best wishes,
Frivole